Computerized Cognitive Training Annotated Research Bibliography

Captain's Log Specific Research
Memory, Cognitive Dysfunctions and ADHD Symptoms
Multiple Sclerosis
Schizophrenia
Stroke
Traumatic Brain Injury
Parkinson's Disease
Alzheimer's and Dementia

Captain's Log Specific Research

1) A study currently underway at Duke University which is attempting to assess the impact of computerized attention training and computerized instruction on measures of student attention, academic achievement, academic productivity, and student behavior. 
Link to Article

2) A study conducted at the Center for the Study of Special Populations (See note below.) was designed to evaluate the effectiveness of commercially available computerized cognitive training (Captain's Log) and neurofeedback (EEG brain wave biofeedback) treatment in helping to improve the functioning of children diagnosed as having an ADHD disorder. A total of 71 participants (85% males) between the ages of 8 and 11, and diagnosed by either a physician or a psychologist as having ADHD, completed the study. The volunteers were randomly assigned to the following three groups: 1) Cognitive Training, 2) Neurofeedback or 3) No Treatment. Each person in the two treatment groups was provided 20 half- hour sessions over a 10 week period. A battery of tests and parent rating scales were administered at the beginning and end of the study using test examiners who were "blind" to group affiliation.

These tests supported the efficacy of the Captain's Log computerized cognitive training system in helping to significantly improve the ability to focus and sustain attention, to encode and retrieve visual and auditory information and to increase the speed of mental processing. Cognitive training also significantly improved emotional and psychological functioning by apparently decreasing ADHD symptoms. One test rating scale of Hyperactivity also showed significant decreases in ADHD symptoms. On another scale of Hyperactivity no decreases were observed, possibly because this group's mean scale score to start was already below the clinical cut-off level for Impulsive-Hyperactive behaviors.

Back To Top

Neurofeedback treatment was found to be more specific in its benefits, and the evidence indicates that this treatment helped to reduce impulsive, hyperactive, and off-task behaviors for individuals who initially presented as significantly more impaired than the other two treatment groups in terms of Impulsive-Hyperactive behaviors. At the end of treatment for this group of individuals, the mean score, which was initially clinically elevated based on the Conner's Impulsive- Hyperactive scale, decreased to below the clinical cut-off level. However, only the one area of memory related to an increased ability for immediate auditory recall showed improvement, and verbal recall of a story significantly declined. Thus, the neurofeedback treatment did not seem as reliable or broadly effective in improving attention, concentration and memory skills as cognitive training. While our understanding of who will best benefit from cognitive training and neurofeedback and how these new techniques may best be used is limited at this time, it is hoped that these findings will encourage further controlled research in these areas.

Finally, of great interest is the surprising finding of this study that no treatment at all for children with ADHD during the summertime led to a pervasive worsening of their emotional and behavioral problems. The No Treatment group also showed no gains whatsoever in cognitive functioning on the objective tests. It is not clear to this researcher what kind of activities (e.g., camp, day care, summer school, vacations, etc.) these children participated in during the summer. However, the lack of regular tasks and exercises demanding focused attention, concentration, sitting still and increasing response inhibition clearly appears to be detrimental to the mental health and well being of ADHD children.

Based on this research, these new techniques show great promise as components in the multi-modal treatment of ADHD. It may prove beneficial to combine cognitive training and neurofeedback for some individuals. The traditional approaches of psychotherapy, behavior modification, school modifications, family therapy and parent education can all be integrated and combined with these new approaches. While our understanding of who will best benefit from cognitive training and neurofeedback and how these new techniques may best be used is limited at this time, it is hoped that these findings will encourage further controlled research in these areas.

Note: This analysis is based on independently conducted research completed during the Summer of 1993 at the Center for the Study of Special Populations, California State Polytechnic University, Pomona, California, by Drs. Aubrey Fine and Larry Goldman. The interpretation and views expressed in this analysis of the study's findings are those solely of Dr. Sandford who has the other authors' permission to disseminate their findings and his own analysis of the results.

3) A therapeutic experiment was conducted to investigate the influence of Captain’s Log. The behavior and cognitive abilities of 4 severely emotionally disturbed children with (ADHD), ages 7 to 11 over a 16-week period using 64 training sessions.. Children were assessed using behavioral scales, spectral electroencephalograms, and intelligence and performance tests both pre- and post-treatment. Results support the expectation that children who were most successful in the training would demonstrate the highest levels of generalization of those skills that were the focus of treatment.

Ref: Slate S., E., Meyer T., L., Burns W., J., Montgomery D., D. “Computerized Cognitive Training for Severely Emotionally Disturbed Children with ADHD.” Behavior Modification. 1998 Jul; 22(3): 415-37.

4) Patients with chronic psychiatric disorders have been found to have neuropsychological deficits. This study examined the effectiveness of computer administered cognitive rehabilitation on 69 inpatients diagnosed with psychotic disorders at a V.A. Medical Center. The treatment group (N = 40) showed significant improvement on most memory subtests of the Wechsler Memory Scale, as well as on the Trailmaking Test (Parts A and B), and reported significantly fewer cognitive complaints. Control subjects (N = 29) showed no changes on these variables. These results indicate that psychiatric patients can productively work with computers, and that computer-assisted cognitive rehabilitation can produce short-term improvements in psychiatric inpatients' cognitive performance.

Ref:  Burda, P.C., Starkey, T.W., Dominguez, F., & Vera, V. "Computer-Assisted Cognitive Rehabilitation of Chronic Psychiatric Inpatients." Computers in Human Behavior. 1994 10(3): 359-368.

Back To Top

5) Adults diagnosed with mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI) or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) were treated with EEG Biofeedback and cognitive training. Psychological and neuropsychological tests were completed at pre-treatment and post-treatment and compared to a normal control group that did not receive training, but was tested on two occasions. The results showed significant improvement on full scale attention and full scale response control score on the IVA Continuous Performance Test. in the mTBI and ADHD groups compared to the control group. Errors on a problem solving task decreased only in the mTBI group.

Ref: Tinius, T., & Tinius, K.A. "Changes After EEG Biofeedback and Cognitive Retraining in Adults with Mild Traumatic Brain Injury and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder." Journal of Neurotherapy. 2000-2001; 4(2) 27.

6) This case study was one of the first to find cognitive training to be an effective non-drug treatment approach for individuals with ADHD. This research involved a 13-year-old Caucasian male who was diagnosed with ADHD. The researchers used the Captain’s Log® cognitive training system to systematically train the subject for a total of 35 sessions. Informal verbal reports from the parents and teacher of the youth indicated that this individual’s behavior had significantly improved. According to his teacher, he was able to stay on task longer and was less disruptive in class. His grades also significantly improved from failing grades to above average performance. His mother noticed that she did not have to spend as much time monitoring his behavior.

These researchers reported that computerized cognitive training was well received by this young man. He enjoyed the tasks and liked the intrinsic rewards that were associated with completing the tasks. In addition, the researchers stated that computer-assisted cognitive training programs such as Captain’s Log® can be easily adapted into classroom settings, since most school systems make computers available to pupils.

For this individual the traditional treatments used to treat ADHD, which included medication, along with individual and group therapy, had not proven to be helpful. Cognitive training did lead to improvements in school and home functioning. These improvements were generally maintained seven months after the treatment was concluded. Sufficient functional improvement was obtained that it was possible to successfully mainstream this student. On followup he was still in regular classes and was reported by his mother to be coping well and meeting the demands of his schoolwork.

Ref: Kotwal, D.B., Burns, W.J., & Montgomery, D.D. "Computer-assisted cognitive training for ADHD." Behavior Modification. 1996; 20. 85-96.

7) Due to a traumatic brain injury, this 31 year old patient required a bilateral temporal lobectomy. At 4 months post surgery testing revealed poor immediate and delayed recall. Following a four month intervention using a computer-assisted cognitive retraining program (Captain's Log) to supplement traditional rehabilitation, a dramatic increase in visual memory was documented. Except for this dramatic improvement, other functional abilities were found to show only expected recovery patterns. This study suggests that patients with bilateral temporal lobectomy may be more amenable to intervention than was previously believed and offers some evidence for the effectiveness of computer-assisted cognitive retraining.

Ref: Steinhardt, M., Montgomery, D., Burns, W., Bat-Ami, M., & DiCowden, M. "Cognitive Rehabilitation of a 31 Year Old Bitemporal Lobectomy Patient." Distributed by permission of the authors. Pre-publication, please do not cite.

8) An experiment was conducted to investigate the influence of Captain’s Log (a computerized cognitive-training system) on the behaviors and performance capabilities of 4 severely emotionally disturbed children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), ages 7 to 11. Behavioral scales, spectral electroencephalograms, and intelligence and performance tests were assessed pre- and post-treatment. A behavioral point system and monitoring of progress on computer tasks were used throughout treatment to evaluate ongoing improvements. There were 64 training sessions administered over a 16-week period. Outcome of treatment was determined by computer advancement, changes in behavioral points, and pre- and post-measures. Results support the expectation that children who were most successful in the training would demonstrate the highest levels of generalization of those skills that were the focus of treatment.

Ref:  Slate, S.E., Meyer, T.L., Burns, W.J., Montgomery, D.D. "Computerized Cognitive Training for Severely Emotionally Disturbed Children with ADHD." Behavior Modification. 1998 July; 22(3) 415-437.

Back To Top


Generalized Cognitive Training Research

Memory, Cognitive Dysfunctions and ADHD Symptoms

1) Cognitive training when combined with medication for children with ADHD was
found to significantly decrease impulsivity when compared to a control group that received medication only and to another control group that was treated using behavior modification techniques. The impulsivity was assessed using the Gordon CPT.

Ref: Hall, C.W., Kataria, S., “Effects of Two Treatment Techniques on Delay and Vigilance Tasks with Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disorder (ADHD) Children.” The Journal of Psychology. 1992 January. 126(1): 17-25.
Link to Article

2) This is a well-controlled study demonstrating that computerized cognitive training can be used to improve working memory and that participants were able to retain the improvements three months after training was completed.

Ref: Klingberg T., Fernell E., Olesen PJ., Johnson M., Gustafsson P., Dahlstrom K., Gillberg CG., Forssberg H., Westerberg H. “Computerized Training of Working Memory in Children with ADHD--A Randomized, Controlled Trial.” Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. 2005 Feb; 44(2): 177-86.
Link to Article

3) This study showed that working memory skills which underlie complex reasoning could be trained in children with ADHD and in adolescents without any diagnosed psychiatric disorders. The study used a control group and also found that cognitive training of working memory generalized to other cognitive skills that were assessed. The cognitive training treatment also led to the reduction of excessive hyperactive motor activity.

Ref: Klingberg, T., Forssberg, H., Westerberg, H., “Training of Working Memory in Children with ADHD.” Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology. 2002 Sep; 24(6): 781-91.
Link to Article

4) An article from APA discussing the potential of helping children with ADHD by training their working memory skills. It also contains a brief review of the importance and limitations of working memory capacity.
Link to Article


Back To Top

5) This article in Scientific American discusses how training the brain for many children with ADHD may be just as effective as the traditional medication treatment approach albeit requiring more patience and effort on the part of parents, teachers, and therapists.

Ref: Sinha, G. “Training The Brain: Cognitive Therapy as an Alternative to ADHD Drugs.” Scientific American. July 11, 2005.
Link to Article

6) The results of this study found that cognitive training specifically designed to promote the generalization of classroom tasks improved both the classroom behavior and the academic achievement of hyperactive children.

Ref: Cameron, M.I., Robinson, V.M. “Effects of Cognitive Training on Academic and On-Task Behavior of Hyperactive Children.” Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology. 1980 Sep; 8(3): 405-19.
Link to Article

7) The intensive training of visual tracking and scanning skills using computer games was found to improve these specific skills. This improvement was found in those participants with attentional difficulties and it did not matter if they also had other cognitive dysfunctions. Individuals with only attention problems and those with both attention difficulties and cognitive dysfunction improved equally well.

Ref: Larose, S., Gagnon, S., Ferland, C., Pepin, M. “Psychology of Computers: XIV. Cognitive Rehabilitation Through Computer Games.” Perceptual and Motor Skills. 1989 Dec; 69(3 Pt 1): 851-8.
Link to Article

8) This study indicated that home-based cognitive training can improve some attentional and memory functions and can also facilitate the learning of cognitive strategies.

Ref: Boman, L., Lindstedt, M., Hemmingsson, H., Bartfai, A. “Cognitive Training in Home Environment.” Brain Injury. 2004 Oct; 18(10): 985-995.

Back To Top


Multiple Sclerosis

9) Three studies were found that supported the effectiveness of cognitive rehabilitation in improving the functioning of individuals with Multiple Sclerosis and are discussed in this review paper.

Ref: Thomas P. W., Thomas, S., Hillier, C., Galvin, K., Baker, R. “Psychological Interventions for Multiple Sclerosis.” Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2006 Jan 25;(1):CD004431.

Link to Article


Schizophrenia

10) This study showed significant improvement in the cognitive functioning of 80 patients with Schizophrenia who received computerized cognitive training. The study was completed in Germany.

Ref: Bender, S., Thienel, R., Dittman-Balcar, A., Tackenberg, A., Gastpar, M. “Training Effects of Computer-based Cognitive Training in Patients with Schizophrenia”. University of Essen. Clinic for Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, Germany.
Link to Article

11) This is a study demonstrated the effectiveness of Cognitive Rehabilitation for Schizophrenia and that it resulted in specific improvements in cognitive flexibility and memory when compared to a traditional occupational therapy treatment program. Also, the results indicated that psychosocial skills were improved; supporting the generalization of the cognitive rehabilitation treatment.

Ref: Wykes, T., Reeder, C., Corner, J., Williams, C., Everitt, B. “The Effects of Neurocognitive Remediation on Executive Processing in Patients with Schizophrenia.” Schizophrenia Bulletin. 1999; 25(2): 291-307.
Link to Article


Back To Top

12) This study shows that specific cognitive training exercises combined with work therapy for schizophrenic patients led to an increase in working memory when compared to a treatment group that received only work therapy.
It also showed that the cognitive training effects endured for 6 months.

Ref: Bell, M., Bryson, G., Wexler, B.E., “Cognitive Remediation of Working Memory Deficits: Durability of Training Effects in Severely Impaired and Less Severely Impaired Schizophrenia.” Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica. 2003 Aug; 108(2): 101-109(9).

13) Improvements in verbal memory for individuals with Schizophrenia were found after cognitive training involving auditory processing. The control group did not show any improvement.

Ref: Fiszdon, J. M.; Whelahan, H., Bryson, G. J.; Wexler, B. E., Bell, M. D. “Cognitive Training of Verbal Memory using a Dichotic Listening Paradigm: Impact on Symptoms and Cognition.” Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica. 2005 Sep; 112(3): 87-193(7).

14) This study addressed the potential problems that computerized cognitive training could have for individuals with Schizophrenia. The concern was that computer-assisted cognitive training might create feelings of anxiety for those individuals with Schizophrenia. After 5 weeks of training these researchers found that the patients reported a significant increase in self-esteem and feelings of well-being. Also, there was a significant decrease in computer anxiety, which was not initially high. The trainees reported that the training was fun and that they perceived that their cognitive abilities were improved by it. Thus, only positive emotional effects were found for computerized cognitive training by individuals suffering from Schizophrenia. Online Article (text is in German)

15) This study found that after cognitive training 52% of schizophrenia patients who were impaired on at least one of the memory tasks normalized their performance on at least one of those tasks. The researchers concluded that clinically meaningful improvement may be possible using cognitive rehabilitation and that the preponderance of the clinical research supports improvements in cognitive skills through cognitive training for patients with schizophrenia. This study was important in that it used a community based, non-psychiatric control for comparison of the effectiveness of cognitive training.

Ref: Bell, M., Fiszdon, J., Bryson, G., Wexler, B. “Effects of Neurocognitive Enhancement Therapy in Schizophrenia: Normalisation of Memory Performance.” Cognitive Neuropsychiatry. 2004; 9(3). 199-211.

Back To Top


Stroke

16) The Veteran's Administration Hospital treatment guidelines for Stroke recommends cognitive rehabilitation. Online Article.
Link to Article

17) This study showed that cognitive rehabilitation can be used to improve memory in stroke patients.

Ref: Cuesta, G.M., “Cognitive Rehabilitation of Memory Following Stroke. Theory, Practice, and Outcome.” Advances in Neurology. 2003; 92: 415-21.
Link to Article


Traumatic Brain Injury

18) While EEG Biofeedback apparently constitutes a direct way of normalizing one’s EEG, computerized cognitive rehabilitation achieves the same results, but in a more indirect way. The purpose of this study is to test the relationship between cognitive rehabilitation and changes in the EEG patterns in TBI patients with attention deficits. Participants were five individuals with TBI, out of medication and at least one year post-injury. Post-testing demonstrated improvement in attention (mainly in sustained, alternating and selective attention) following cognitive training, and correlated with self-reports. EEG changes accompanied these improvements. Further analysis of the EEG changes are underway. These findings need to be replicated in a larger study.

Ref: Stathopoulou S., & Lubar J.F. "EEG Changes on TBI Patients During Cognitive Tasks after Cognitive Rehabilitation." Presented at the ISNR Convention. Monterey, CA., 2001.

19) A computerized cognitive rehabilitation approach for memory enhancement with TBI patients was found to be similar in its effectiveness when compared to a therapist directed cognitive rehabilitation memory training program. Both treatment approaches showed a significant improvement in memory skills after training when compared to a no treatment control group.

Back To Top

Ref: Dou, Z.L., Man, D.W., Ou, H.N., Zheng, J.L., Tam, S.F. “Computerized Errorless Learning-based Memory Rehabilitation for Chinese Patients with Brain Injury: A Preliminary Quasi-experimental Clinical Design Study.” Brain Injury. 2006 Mar; 20(3): 219-25.
Link to Article

20) This study looked at TBI patients with working memory problems and used a cognitive rehabilitation treatment program to specifically train them to improve their working memory skills. The treatment group was compared to other TBI patients who had processing speed problems but did not have problems with their working memory abilities. The control group did not show any improvement in memory skills after undergoing the cognitive remediation therapy.

Ref: Serino, A., Ciaramelli, E., Di Santantonio, A., Ladavas, E., “A Rehabilitative Program for Central Executive Deficits after Traumatic Brain Injury.” Brain and Cognition. 2006 Mar; 60(2): 213-4.
Link to Article

21) Adolescents and children with attention and memory deficits after acquired brain injury were treated for about 3 hours per week for 17 weeks using cognitive training exercises. The control group participate in a freely chosen interactive activity for the same amount of time. Pre- and post-training assessments were made using a neuropsychological test battery. Improvements in sustained and selective attention as well as in memory performance were shown in the treatment group as compared to control group.

Ref: Van't Hoogt, I., Andersson, K., Bergman, B., Sejersen, T., von Wendt, L., Bartfai, A. “Beneficial Effect from a Cognitive Training Programme on Children with Acquired Brain Injuries Demonstrated in a Controlled Study.” Brain Injury. 2005 Jul; 19(7) 511-518.

22) Over 95% of rehabilitation facilities who serve individuals with brain injuries and strokes provide cognitive rehabilitation. This landmark, meta-analysis study, which reviewed 171 published articles, found compelling evidence of the effectiveness of cognitive rehabilitation for the remediation of attention, memory, functional communication and higher level executive skills. The article provides specific, evidence-based recommendations for cognitive rehabilitation to help guide clinicians in their work.

Ref: Cicerone, K.D., Dahlberg, C., Kalmar, K., Langenbahn, D.M., Malec, J.F., Bergquist, T.F., Felicetti, T.,  Giacino, J.T., Harley, J.P., Harrington, D.E., Herzog., J., Kneipp, S., Laatsch, L., Morse, P.A. "Evidence Based Cognitive Rehabilitation: Recommendations for Clinical Practice. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. 2000; 81(12) 1596-1615.

Back To Top


Parkinson’s Disease

23) This study found that specific cognitive rehabilitation training is needed to improve executive, higher level mental functioning in Parkinson's patients. Half of the patients were randomly assigned to the cognitive rehabilitation treatment group and the other half received the standard medical treatment for Parkinson's disease. The cognitive training group significantly improved on two measures of executive functioning and no improvement was found in the standard treatment group.

Ref: Sammer, G., Reuter, I., Hullmann, K., Kaps, M., Vaitl, D. “Training of Executive Functions in Parkinson's Disease.” Journal of Neurological Sciences. 2006 Jun 8. Prepublication.
Link to Article


Alzheimer’s and Dementia


24) A meta-analysis review of cognitive training for Alzheimer's patients found that it was effective for the restoration of learning, memory, executive functioning, activities of daily living and general cognitive problems.

Ref: Sitzer, D.I., Twamley, E.W., Jeste, D.V. “Cognitive Training in Alzheimer's Disease: A Meta-analysis of the Literature.” Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica. 2006 Aug; 114(2): 75-90.

25) This study showed that in older people computerized cognitive training led to improvements in working memory, processing speed, learning skills and the ability to not be effected by interference when learning. Some of these abilities were able to be maintained 5 months after training was completed. The researchers concluded that computerized cognitive training is an effective way to treat declines in cognitive functioning that often occur as people age.

Back To Top

Ref: Gunther, V.K., Schafer, P. Holzner, B.J., Kemmler, G.W. “Long-term Improvements in Cognitive Performance through Computer-assisted Cognitive Training: A Pilot Study in a Residential Home for Older People.” Aging and Mental Health. 2003 May; 7(3): 200-206.

26) This review of the literature suggests that cognitive decline is neither universal, pervasive, or irreversible. It also identified research studies which demonstrated that older adults can benefit from cognitive training.

Ref: Thompson, G., Foth, D. “Cognitive-Training Programs for Older Adults: What Are they and Can they Enhance Mental Fitness?” Educational Gerontology. 2005 Sep; 31(8): 603-626.

27) A collaborative approach involving cognitive training resulted in the maintenance of its benefits when compared in their working individually.

Ref: Saczynski, J., Margrett, J., Willis, S. “Older Adults' Strategic Behavior: Effects of Individual versus Collaborative Cognitive Training.” Educational Gerontology. 2004 Aug; 30(7): 587-610.
Link to Article

28) Based on single-case designs and small group studies these researchers were positive about the benefits and value of cognitive training for early-onset Alzheimer's disease.

Ref: Clare, L., Woods, R., “Cognitive Training and Cognitive Rehabilitation for People with Early-stage Alzheimer's disease: A Review.” Neuropsychological Rehabilitation. 2004 Sep; 14(4): 385-401.

29) This book which discusses the NIH funded research with Nuns that shows how stimulating and using your brain is the one of the best ways to prevent the development of Alzheimer's disease. The Nun Study is a longitudinal study of aging and Alzheimer's disease funded by the National Institute on Aging. Participants were 678 American members of the School Sisters of Notre Dame religious congregation who were 75 to 106 years of age.

Ref: Snowdon, D., “Aging with Grace: What the Nun Study Teaches Us about Leading Longer, Healthier, and More Meaningful Lives.” 2001.
Link to Article


Back To Top

30) In fact, there is now enough research supporting the effectiveness of cognitive training that the Alzheimer’s Association is offering free classes around the country to teach people — of any age, but especially baby boomers — just how to do it. They call it “maintain your brain.” More information is provided in an online article that discusses how training your brain helps you to keep it alive throughout your life.
Link to Article

31) An article related to how to keep your brain young called: 11 Steps to a better Brain.
Link to Article

32) Maintain your brain using recommendations from the Alzheimer's Association.
Link to Article

33) An article that discussing ways to keep your brain mentally active.
Link to Article

34) What the AARP says about improving your brain.
Link to Article

35) How the brain works in simple language from the AARP website.
Link to Article

36) Staying sharp using an AARP program.
Link to Article

37) A website for the latest breaking “Brain News.”
Link to Article

38) This online article discusses that researchers found the most compelling convincing evidence to date that complex mental activity across people's lives significantly reduces the risk of dementia. The researchers found that "exercising" the brain almost halves the incidence of dementia.
Link to Article

Back To Top

 

Success Stories  |  IVA+Plus Research  |  Cognitive Training Research

Professional Training  |  About BrainTrain  |  Customer Service | Technical Support

Free Leases for Veterans | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | Terms


Copyright ©2009. All Rights Reserved. Contact Webmaster